Our Review Methodology: Criteria and Scoring System 2026 Casino
How Often Scores Are Reviewed
A score is only as good as the information behind it. We revisit a review when the operator changes a key term — a new welcome offer, different wagering, added or removed payment methods — and after a significant app update. Reader reports of a mismatch trigger a check sooner. Every review shows the date it was last checked.
What Our Method Cannot Tell You
Our scores describe published terms and the product as it is presented, not outcomes. They cannot predict whether you will win, how a particular withdrawal will go or how support will handle your individual case. Luck and personal experience vary widely, and terms can change between our check and your visit — the operator's current terms always take precedence.
How the Score Works
Each criterion is rated from 1 to 10, and the overall score is a weighted average of those ratings, rounded to one decimal place.
- 9–10: clear, fair terms with no significant issues found.
- 7–8: solid, with a few conditions worth reading carefully.
- 5–6: usable, but with notable drawbacks.
- Below 5: problems serious enough that we advise caution.
Applying the Method to Pin-Up
For Pin-Up, we read the welcome offer's wagering rules, maximum bet and expiry; list the deposit and withdrawal options displayed for Australian users and their stated limits; walk through the APK installation and the mobile site; and look at how responsible gambling tools are presented. Each criterion gets its own rating with a short reason, and the overall figure on the review page is the weighted result of those ratings.
What We Assess
We look at six areas:
- bonus terms and how transparent they are;
- payment options, limits and stated processing times;
- game and betting range;
- the mobile app and mobile website;
- customer support channels;
- clarity of the general terms, including verification and responsible gambling tools.
What Pulls a Score Down
Ratings drop for wagering conditions that are hidden or hard to find, unclear maximum-win caps, withdrawal rules that differ from what a promotion suggests, missing or hard-to-reach support, verification demands that appear only at cash-out, and weak or buried responsible gambling tools. A pattern of these issues can outweigh a generous headline bonus.